| Year | Location | Winner |
| 1991 | Colombia | Karen Redfern (Bra) |
| 1992 | Brazil | Karen Redfern (Bra) |
| 1993 | Argentina | Demer Holleran (USA) |
| 1994 | Colombia | Adriana Moura (Bra) |
| 1995 | Argentina | Heather Ann Wallace (Can) |
| 1996 | Colombia | Adriana Moura (Bra) |
| 1997 | Mexico | |
| 1998 | Guatemala | |
| 1999 | Canada | Melanie Jans (Can) |
| 2000 | Brazil | Delmy Huerte (Mex) |
| 2001 | San Salvador | Diana Huerta (Mex) |
| 2002 | Ecuador | Samantha Teran (Mex) |
| 2003 | Republica Dominicana | Latasha Khan (USA) |
| 2004 | Mexico | Samantha Teran (Mex) |
| 2005 | El Salvador | Alana Miller (Can) |
| 2006 | Colombia | Samantha Teran (Mex) |
| 2007 | Brazil | Natalie Grainger (USA) |
| 2008 | Ecuador | Silvia Angulo (Col) |
| 2009 | Ecuador | Samantha Teran (Mex) |
| 2010 | Guatemala | Samantha Teran (Mex) |
| 2011 | Mexico | Samantha Teran (Mex) |
| 2012 | Ecuador | Diana Garcia (Mex) |
| 2013 | Argentina | Amanda Sobhy (USA) |
| 2014 | Mexico | Samantha Teran (Mex) |
| 2015 | Canada | Amanda Sobhy (USA) |
| 2016 | United States | Mariam Kamal (USA) |
| 2017 | Argentina | Samantha Teran (Mex) |
| 2018 | Cayman Islands | Amanda Sobhy (USA) |